Most U.S. home sellers pay a total commission of 5% to 6% of the sale price, historically divided between the listing brokerage and the buyer’s brokerage. On a $400,000 sale, that’s roughly $20,000 to $24,000 gone before you see a dime. No law sets that rate, though, and the 2024 industry rule changes have made who pays the buyer’s agent a live negotiation rather than a given.
Commission is almost always the single biggest line item deducted at your closing, larger than title fees, transfer taxes, and prorated property taxes combined. It’s worth understanding exactly where the money goes and what you can actually push on, because a half-point either way moves your take-home by thousands.
How much do sellers actually pay?
The combined rate lands between 5% and 6% in most markets. Discount and flat-fee brokerages advertise less; luxury and slow-moving listings sometimes run higher. Because it’s a percentage, the check scales with your price, one reason $1M sellers have far more leverage to negotiate than $250K sellers do.
| Sale price | At 5% | At 5.5% | At 6% |
|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 | $12,500 | $13,750 | $15,000 |
| $400,000 | $20,000 | $22,000 | $24,000 |
| $600,000 | $30,000 | $33,000 | $36,000 |
| $850,000 | $42,500 | $46,750 | $51,000 |
These are illustrative, not quotes. Before you sign a listing agreement, run your own price, mortgage payoff, and closing costs through the Seller Net Proceeds Calculator so you’re looking at a real net number, not a sale price.
How does the commission split between agents?
The total is shared by two brokerages: yours (the listing side) and the buyer’s. A 6% total has traditionally been described as roughly 3% to each side, though the division is set by agreement and shifts case to case.
Here’s the part sellers rarely picture: your agent doesn’t pocket their whole half. That 3% gets split again with their brokerage under whatever contract they’re on, and the agent pays for photography, staging advice, signage, and marketing out of what’s left. A single commission check on your sale can end up feeding a listing agent, a listing brokerage, a buyer’s agent, and a buyer’s brokerage. The number that lands in any one person’s account is a fraction of what leaves your proceeds.
Is commission negotiable?
Yes, and anyone who tells you the rate is “standard” is telling you their preference, not the law. No regulation sets commission, and antitrust rules actually forbid the industry from fixing prices. The percentage, the structure, and what’s included are all fair game.
Your leverage depends on price point, condition, and how fast the home will move. A turnkey house in a hot ZIP code gives you room to ask; a fixer that needs heavy marketing gives you less. Worth putting on the table:
- The listing-side percentage itself.
- Whether, and how much, you offer toward the buyer’s agent.
- A flat fee or tiered structure instead of a straight percentage.
- What’s actually bundled in, professional photos, floor plans, ad spend.
What changed about commissions in 2024?
A 2024 legal settlement involving the National Association of Realtors rewrote several long-standing practices, with rules taking effect in August 2024. It didn’t cap or set rates. It changed how buyer-agent pay is arranged and disclosed. Two shifts matter most:
- No buyer-agent pay posted on the MLS. Offers of compensation to a buyer’s agent can no longer be advertised on the Multiple Listing Service. They can still be negotiated, just not broadcast there.
- Written buyer agreements. Buyers now generally sign an agreement spelling out how their agent gets paid before they start touring homes.
For sellers, the upshot is simple: whether you contribute to the buyer’s agent, and how much, is now an explicit line you negotiate instead of an assumed cost baked into the listing. Practice still varies by state, so confirm what’s customary with a local agent before you decide.
How does commission hit your net proceeds?
Commission comes straight off the top at closing. You don’t write a check; it’s netted out of the sale before the wire hits your account. The math that determines what you walk away with:
- Sale price minus
- Remaining mortgage payoff minus
- Total agent commission minus
- Other closing costs (title, transfer taxes, prorated property taxes, attorney or escrow fees) equals
- Your net proceeds
Because the commission tracks your sale price, small rate changes swing your take-home more than people expect. The fastest way to see it is to plug two rates into the Seller Net Proceeds Calculator and read the bottom lines side by side. One caveat that trips sellers up: any gain on the sale can carry its own tax consequences separate from commission, so loop in a tax pro if you’re near the capital-gains exclusion limits.
Frequently asked questions
Who pays the commission, the buyer or the seller?
The seller has traditionally paid it out of proceeds, covering both agents. Since the 2024 changes, how much the seller puts toward the buyer’s agent is negotiated openly rather than assumed.
What’s a typical commission rate?
About 5% to 6% of the sale price combined, though it moves with your market, price, and brokerage. It’s set by agreement, not by law, so it’s negotiable.
Can I sell without paying any commission?
You can skip a listing agent’s fee by going for-sale-by-owner, but you take on the pricing, marketing, and paperwork yourself, and you may still choose to offer something to a buyer’s agent to attract showings.
How is the commission actually paid?
It’s deducted from your proceeds at closing and disbursed to the brokerages. You never write a separate check; it just lowers your net.
Did commissions drop after the 2024 rules?
The rules didn’t mandate lower rates. They changed how buyer-agent pay is advertised and agreed to. Whether your total cost moves comes down to what you negotiate.
Is commission tax-deductible for sellers?
It’s treated as a selling expense that reduces your taxable gain, not a straight deduction. How it plays out depends on your numbers, so check with a tax professional.
Keep more of what you earn with cleaner books
Whether you’re selling your own home or you’re an agent living on commission, knowing where every dollar goes is half the fight. For 1099 pros, that means tracking commission income, expenses, and deductions all year instead of scrambling in April. Tabby is AI bookkeeping built for self-employed and 1099 workers, including real estate agents, so your income and write-offs stay organized automatically. Start a free trial and spend less time in spreadsheets and more time closing deals.
